Assignment 3 – Self Portrait: Final Rework

Introduction to Rework

Following my tutor’s initial feedback (here) and subsequent conversations I have reworked the presentation of assignment 3 for a second time. I have built on his comments regarding the contact sheet for this series by building in a opening contact sheet or grid which potentially suggests a narrative. The individual spreads are significantly changed with much tighter displays of, mostly, square images to the left and a full bleed horizontal aspect image to the right. Each spread has an obvious theme, such as landscape, wood, stone, iron, or street but I have not included any text, thus, allowing the viewer to bring their own context to the series.

I have reflected on the tutor’s comments regarding the lack of direct engagement between my shadow and the environment but have not added any new images that directly respond to this point. Part of my original thinking was that I use a camera as a protective layer to avoid too much social interaction and this sense of being there but not completely included is an important facet of the series if it is to reflect that idea.

The Original Introduction

Susan Bright’s (1) argues that the self portrait is a photographic compulsion, an argument supported by the rise of the selfie (see here), but in nearly fifty years of photography I cannot remember taking a single, intentional self portrait. Self portraiture is a broad church full of different approaches (i), with each approach revealing something of  the photographer’s nature, so I conclude that not having succumbed to self photography must also be revealing.

Self portraiture is an enquiry into identity, if we intend to use ourselves as a subject we must answer the fundamental questions of “who am I, where do I fit into the world?” But is the answer how we see ourselves or how others see us? Like the interpretation of a photograph, our persona is contextual, we are defined by our education, surroundings, profession, possessions, family and associations, these contexts establish our status within society and, much as we like to think we are independent and self led, most of us tend to play the role expected of us. (ii)

Historically many societies have interpreted the shadow as proof of existence, the visible representation of our soul, the original paradox, the intangible object that proves the substance of the tangible subject (iii).  I have set this series in a shadow world where the three dimensional signifiers of my identity are absent, the audience only sees my shade, my essential essence in the landscape of my choice. This incognito, ambiguous presence, fits my self perception. Over the years I have used the camera as a way to keep my distance, the observer, the watcher, the recorder of events attended but not quite part of, the missing face in the group photograph.

The shadow self portrait has deep roots in the history of art and I positioned my series in this context (iv), referencing my images, not just to photographers such as Friedlander, Maier and Stielglitz but to other artists like Renoir and Monet. By connecting my series in this way I intended to access their symbolism and to develop three primary ideas, the “shadow of the gaze”, the “shadow of the creative hand” and the “transition between reflection and shadow”. (v) (vi) But overall I am exploring how my shadow relates to the landscape I typically photograph so this series has become a discourse on the act of my photography.

The Series

shades-and-shadows-v5-pages-2

 

The Spreads

-

 

The Individual Pages

shades-and-shadows-v5-pages-8

shades-and-shadows-v5-pages-9

shades-and-shadows-v5-pages-10

shades-and-shadows-v5-pages-11

shades-and-shadows-v5-pages-12

shades-and-shadows-v5-pages-13

shades-and-shadows-v5-pages-14

shades-and-shadows-v5-pages-15

shades-and-shadows-v5-pages-16

shades-and-shadows-v5-pages-17

Research and Develoment

This project has had a long gestation period. The original concept was to work with reflections but this quite quickly developed into using shadows. My research built on those early ideas.

  1. Very Early Ideas and Research for Assignment 3
  2. Vivian Maier: Self Portraits
  3. Reflective Self Portrait: Henri, Friedlander, Steele-Perkins and Scianna
  4. Shadow Self Portrait
  5. The Mysterious Shadow
  6. The History of the Shadow Self Portrait
  7. Shadow Self Portrait Contact Sheets
  8. Black and White Processing
  9. Selfie or Self Portrait
  10. Themes in Assignment 3 Self Portrait
  11. Assignment 3 Self Portrait
  12. Assignment 3 Self Portrait Rework

Notes on Text

(i) I have looked at a number of different ways in which the shadow self portrait has been used by contemporary photographers in an earlier essay Shadow Self Portrait.

(ii) An earlier essay The Mysterious Shadow explores how shadows have been historically interpreted.

(iii) Christopher Butler (2) neatly encapsulates post modernist theory as “discourses put you in your place”; our identity becomes the role we are expected to play, and usually do play, as defined by the script approved by society.

(iv) The desire to relate my series back to historical art came from two sources. Firstly my research on Francesca Woodman showed me that contemporary art can be created in the context of an exploration of the history of art, I saw that her understanding of historical conventions fuelled her creativity. In my essay on her work I wrote “I see her more as a product of her upbringing, an intense artist who had an exceptional awareness of the history of, not just her art form, but of sculpture, music, painting and performance”. I was inspired to bring a wider history than just photography into this series. The second motivation came from reading Victor Stoicha (3) and Ernst Gombrich (4). These two books were illuminating and exciting and probably the first books I have ever read by Art Historians as opposed to Photographic Art Historians. They opened my eyes to the idea that the shadow as a subject or as a technique had roots as deep as humankind itself  and I wanted to pursue this theme in my work. 

(v) An earlier essay The History of the Shadow Self Portrait looks at the historic origins and development of these ideas and the use of shadow self portrait in art.

(vi) In the interest of keeping this introduction as near as possible to the required 300 words an explanation of how these themes have been used in this series is included in a separate essay Themes in Assignment 3 Self Portrait

Sources

Books

(1) Bright, Susan (2010) Auto Focus: the Self Portrait in Contemporary Photography. London: Thames and Hudson

(2) Butler, Christopher (2002) Postmodernism: A Very Short Introduction. Kindle Edition. Oxford: Oxford University Press

(3) Stoichita, Victor I. ( 1997) A Short History of the Shadow. London: Reaktion

(4) Gombrich, Ernst (1995) Shadows: the Depiction of Cast Shadows in Western Art. London: National Gallery Publications.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Assignment 3 - Self Portraits and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s